First, whoever decided to do 3 division within the conference is beyond me. Let's not forget the fact that if you were the division winner, you were guaranteed home ice. So, it really did not matter if your division sucked (re: Southeast a few years back). You could have finished with a record under .500 but as long as you won your division, you will get 3rd even though 4th place team might actually finish 15 points higher.
A map of where the teams are currently located in current division
So, they're thinking of going back to 4 division with one conference possibly with 16 teams and the other with 14 teams. What is wrong with 15 each? One 7 teams and one 8 teams in each conference?
Apparently, it's about balance and the fact that 3 teams are complaining (Detroit, Nashville and Columbus).
So, this is how I would realign the divisions...
Pacific, Central, Atlantic, and Northeast
Pacific | Central | Atlantic | Northeast |
---|---|---|---|
Anaheim Ducks | Chicago Blackhawks | Boston Bruins | Buffalo Sabres |
Calgary Flames | Colorado Avalanche | Carolina Hurricanes | Columbus Blue Jackets |
Edmonton Oilers | Dallas Stars | Florida Panthers | Detroit Red Wings |
LA Kings | Minnesota Wilds | New Jersey Devils | Montreal Canadiens |
San Jose Sharks | Nashville Predators | New York Islanders | Philadelphia Flyers |
Phoenix Coyotes | St. Louis Blues | New York Rangers | Pittsburgh Penguins |
Vancouver Canucks | Winnipeg Jets | Tampa Bay Lightnings | Ottawa Senators |
Washington Capitals | Toronto Maple Leafs |
Wow... I didn't know it was a bit more difficult that it could be. Although, it only took me... oh, 8 minutes to put everyone in place. Too bad for Nashville, I couldn't put them in the Eastern Conference... Geographically, they fit better in the Central division...
First, I had to keep Pittsburgh and Philadelphia in the same division, same for New York's 3 teams and Florida and Tampa.
I tried to keep as much of the current divisions in tact. However, Boston had to move to Atlantic so that I could balance out teams on the East coast. So, Pittsburgh and Philadelphia had to move the Northeast.
Alternatively, it could realigned to this:
Pacific | Central | Atlantic | Northeast |
---|---|---|---|
Anaheim Ducks | Chicago Blackhawks | Carolina Hurricanes | Boston Bruins |
Calgary Flames | Colorado Avalanche | Columbus Blue Jackets | Buffalo Sabres |
Edmonton Oilers | Dallas Stars | Detroit Red Wings | Montreal Canadiens |
LA Kings | Minnesota Wilds | Florida Panthers | New Jersey Devils |
San Jose Sharks | Nashville Predators | Philadelphia Flyers | New York Islanders |
Phoenix Coyotes | St. Louis Blues | Pittsburgh Penguins | New York Rangers |
Vancouver Canucks | Winnipeg Jets | Tampa Bay Lightnings | Ottawa Senators |
Washington Capitals | Toronto Maple Leafs |
For the sake of political correctness, I think the first option is better. You now have Detroit in its rightful division with Toronto, Montreal and Boston for Original 6 rivalries and keeping rivalries between the New York teams and Pennsylvania teams in same division.
I have a funny feeling Bettman is itching for expansion of 2 more team so that it's more "rounded." I hope not... We do not need a Las Vegas team or in Kansas City... But there will be no objection to moving the team from Phoenix to Seattle. Nor will there be objection to moving one of the Florida team to Quebec City. Nor will there be objection moving Carolina back to Hartford.
Pacific | Central | Atlantic | Northeast |
---|---|---|---|
Anaheim Ducks | Chicago Blackhawks | Boston Bruins | Buffalo Sabres |
Calgary Flames | Colorado Avalanche | Columbus Blue Jackets | Detroit Red Wings |
Edmonton Oilers | Dallas Stars | Hartford Whalers | Montreal Canadiens |
LA Kings | Minnesota Wilds | New Jersey Devils | Philadelphia Flyers |
San Jose Sharks | Nashville Predators | New York Islanders | Pittsburgh Penguins |
Phoenix/Seattle | St. Louis Blues | New York Rangers | Ottawa Senators |
Vancouver Canucks | Winnipeg Jets | Tampa Bay Lightnings | Quebec Nordiques |
Washington Capitals | Toronto Maple Leafs |
Or... we could get rid of both Florida teams... 28 team league sounds good?? I thought so.
Pacific | Central | Atlantic | Northeast |
---|---|---|---|
Anaheim Ducks | Chicago Blackhawks | Hartford Whalers | Boston Bruins |
Calgary Flames | Colorado Avalanche | New Jersey Devils | Buffalo Sabres |
Edmonton Oilers | Dallas Stars | New York Islanders | Columbus Blue Jackets |
LA Kings | Minnesota Wilds | New York Rangers | Detroit Red Wings |
San Jose Sharks | Nashville Predators | Philadelphia Flyers | Montreal Canadiens |
Phoenix Coyotes | St. Louis Blues | Pittsburgh Penguins | Ottawa Senators |
Vancouver Canucks | Winnipeg Jets | Washington Capitals | Toronto Maple Leafs |